Square field guide

Coffee shop rewards app on Square: your stamp card, in your own app

Your regulars want the tenth drink free, and you want them ordering ahead from a phone with your name on it. A Crate app puts the stamp card right there: earned on every app order and at your Square counter, for $80 a month for up to five shops, with nothing to change at the register.

By the Crate teamUpdated

The short answer

  • Keep the regulars: the card lives in your own app on their home screen, not a receipt link or a shared app that shows them other shops.
  • Keep more each month from your second shop: Square Plus, the plan Square Loyalty comes with, is $49 per location, so $147 a month for three shops against $80 flat. That is $67 a month, $804 a year.
  • Every offer is free to send: a push from your app reaches all your regulars, where Square charges 3 cents a text past the first 500.
  • Nothing changes at the counter: staff type the app's rewards code or the customer's phone into the Square order note and the stamp lands.
Contents
  1. Your options, in dollars
  2. What Square Loyalty costs you
  3. Why not a shared rewards app
  4. A stamp card in your own app
  5. Setting up app rewards
  6. Questions

Your options, in dollars

Coffee shops on Square ask the same questions: is Square Loyalty worth the monthly fee, should it be a free drink or money off, and how do I stop people gaming it? A small coffee shop asking whether Square Loyalty is worth it put it plainly: "every $45 adds up" (Square Community). Another owner of a couple of coffee shops runs 1 star per drink with a free drink at 9 stars and has wondered about switching to money off (Square Community). Here is what each route costs you and what it gets your regulars.

Rewards for a Square coffee shop: what you pay and what your regulars get
Stamp card in your Crate appSquare Loyalty (Square Plus)Paper punch card
Monthly cost, one shop$80, and your own iOS and Android app is included$49Printing
Monthly cost, two shops$80$98Printing
Monthly cost, three shops$80$147Printing
Monthly cost, five shops$80$245Printing
You keep with Crate each monthTwo shops $18, three $67, five $165 ($1,980 a year)
Where your regulars see itThe Rewards tab in your app, every time they orderDigital receipts and your Square siteTheir wallet, until they lose it
Earning at the counterStaff add the app's rewards code or the phone number to the Square order notePhone number on the checkout screenStamp the card
Earning on orders aheadEvery paid app order at or above your minimumSquare Online ordersNo
Seeing their stampsOn the Rewards tab of your app, iPhone and AndroidDigital receipts, or type a phone number and request a codeOn the card
Sending an offer to 2,000 regularsPush from your app, no charge per messageAbout $45 past the first 500 free texts (3 cents each)Not possible
Bringing them backA reminder when a free drink is waiting, and push offers you sendSquare's marketing toolsNone
Square prices from Square's own pages, read November 20, 2026; Square Plus also includes staff and marketing tools. At one shop Square Plus costs $31 a month less, and the Crate price includes your own app; from the second shop Crate costs less. Crate facts from the product as it runs today.

What Square Loyalty costs you

Square sells loyalty as part of a plan now. Its pricing post lists Square Plus at $49 per month per location with "marketing, loyalty, and a customizable website", and a 30-day free trial (Square); the Plus column on Square's pricing page lists the loyalty rewards program (Square). Here is what that means for your shop.

  • Every new shop adds $49 a month. The price is per location, so the second shop doubles it and the third makes it $147. A Crate app stays $80 a month for up to five, so a three-shop owner keeps $67 a month.
  • Your regulars cannot see how close they are. Square's loyalty page says customers sign up at your point of sale, through your Square website or via an invoice (Square). After that, points show only on digital receipts, not printed ones, customers redeem by giving the cashier their name or phone number, and to check a balance they enter their phone number on a status page and request a code; the wallet pass is iPhone only (Square). A reward nobody can see brings nobody back. In your own app the stamp card is on their home screen, on iPhone and Android, one tap from ordering again.
  • Every offer you text costs you. Square Plus lists text marketing as "The first 500 texts are free, then pay 3 cents per text" (Square). One offer to 2,000 customers is about $45 past the free texts. A push offer from your Crate app reaches everyone with your app at no charge per message.
  • Ordering ahead runs through Square's site. Rewards can be claimed through a Square Online site, and invoice payments earn but cannot redeem (Square). With Crate the order ahead and the stamp happen in your app, and the order still lands in Square as a real order.
  • The minimum-spend trick works in both. A coffee shop owner on Square Community put a $5 minimum on earning so customers could not buy cheap drip coffees and claim the most expensive drink free (Square Community). In a Crate app you set that minimum yourself, from $0 to $50.

Why not a shared rewards app

joe, a shared app for independent coffee shops, lists "$0 subscription fees" (joe), which looks cheaper than any plan. The catch is whose customer it is. joe tells coffee drinkers to "Earn rewards that follow you from shop to shop" (joe) and tells shops they can "acquire from other joe shops" (joe), so the reward your regular earned with you can be spent down the street. joe also says "We hold 6% for each loyalty transaction" and puts the effective cost at "approximately 1%" (joe): on $8,000 a month of loyalty sales that is about $80, the whole price of a Crate app, and it rises as you grow. In your own app there is no other shop to tap, and the price stays $80 at any volume. See joe vs your own app for the full comparison.

A stamp card in your own app

Square gives you a website and an ordering profile, not your own app in the App Store. A Crate app is yours, and the stamp card is what brings your regulars back to it: they see their stamps every time they order ahead. It needs no Square Loyalty plan.

  • A free drink they chase. Each paid app order earns a stamp, and the tenth unlocks a free drink: the most expensive drink in the next order, add-ons included. Retail items like bagged coffee do not count toward the free drink.
  • No cheap-drip loophole. You set the order total needed to earn a stamp, from $0 to $50 (it starts at $6), so every stamp is earned on an order worth the drink you give back.
  • Counter regulars earn too. A customer at the register shows the 6-digit rewards code from the app or gives their phone number, staff add it to the Square order note, and Crate adds one stamp for that order. Staff can also enter the code in the Crate dashboard.
  • No regular loses a stamp. A guest who orders with an email or phone that later becomes an account gets the stamp when they sign up, and so does a phone number given at the counter.
  • Redeemed with you, anywhere in your shop. Use the free drink on an app order, or show a 5-minute pass from the app to the barista.
  • A reason to come back this week. Customers get a notice when a free drink unlocks and, by default, a reminder 7 days later if they have not used it. You can also send a push offer to everyone with your app.
  • Money off instead, if you prefer. Crate also has a points mode, for example 10 points per dollar and $5 off at 1,000 points, used on app orders. Ask us to switch it on.

Where it may still fit: Square Loyalty may still fit if you run one shop that is mostly walk-in, already pay for Square Plus, and want tiered rewards; Crate's card is ten stamps for one free drink, and a Crate app does not show Square Loyalty balances yet.

The app is $80/month for up to five locations, with no Crate per-order fee, and every app order lands in Square as a real order. For the full picture of costs and options, see a branded ordering app for your Square business, what a coffee shop app costs, the cafe app comparison and Crate cafe ordering. Moving from another app? See what happens to points and gift cards when you switch.

Setting up app rewards

  1. 01Pick your minimum order for a stamp, just above the price of a drip coffee.
  2. 02Tell staff the counter routine: ask for the rewards code or phone number and type it into the Square order note.
  3. 03Put a sign at the register that the tenth drink is free in the app.
  4. 04Let the app remind customers when a free drink is waiting.

Questions

What is the best rewards app for a Square coffee shop?
One your regulars already open to order. A Crate app puts a stamp card inside your own iOS and Android app on your Square menu: a stamp on every app order and at your Square counter, a free drink on the tenth, and a reminder when it is waiting. It is $80 a month for up to five locations, with no Crate fee per order and no per-location loyalty plan.
How much does Square Loyalty cost?
Square includes loyalty in Square Plus, $49 per month per location, with a 30-day free trial. That is $98 a month for two shops and $147 for three. A Crate app, stamp card included, is $80 a month for up to five, so from your second shop you keep money and your regulars get your own app as well.
Do Square Loyalty points work on online orders?
On Square's own channels, yes: Square says rewards can be claimed through a Square Online site, and invoice payments earn points but cannot redeem them. In a Crate app every paid order in your own app earns a stamp, and so does a Square counter order when staff add the rewards code, so the card lives where your regulars order ahead.
Can my coffee shop have a stamp card without paying for Square Loyalty?
Yes. A Crate app has its own stamp card: one stamp per paid order at or above a minimum you set, and the tenth stamp unlocks a free drink. It runs inside Crate, so it needs no Square Loyalty plan, and it is part of the $80/month app plan for up to five locations.
How do customers check their Square Loyalty balance?
Square says customers redeem by giving the cashier their name or phone number, see points on digital receipts only (not printed ones), and check a balance by entering their phone number on a status page and requesting a code; the wallet pass is iPhone only. In a Crate app the stamps sit on the Rewards tab of your own app, on iPhone and Android, so a regular sees how close the free drink is every time they order.
Does Square charge to text loyalty customers an offer?
Square Plus lists text marketing as "The first 500 texts are free, then pay 3 cents per text", so one offer to 2,000 customers costs about $45 past the free texts. A Crate app sends a push offer to everyone who has your app, with no charge per message, so you can bring regulars back on a slow afternoon without counting texts.
Is a shared rewards app like joe cheaper?
joe charges no subscription, but it holds 6% of each loyalty transaction and puts its own effective cost at about 1%: about $80 a month on $8,000 of loyalty sales, and more as you grow. Its rewards "follow you from shop to shop", so the free drink your regular earns with you can take them to another joe shop. A Crate app is $80 a month at any volume, and every stamp brings the customer back to you.
How do counter customers earn stamps in the app?
The customer shows the 6-digit rewards code from the app, or gives their phone number, and staff type it into the Square order note. Crate adds one stamp for that Square order, or staff can enter the code in the Crate dashboard. If the phone number has no app account yet, the stamp waits until they sign up, so no regular loses a stamp for downloading late.
How do I stop customers buying cheap drinks and claiming an expensive free one?
Set a minimum spend to earn. A coffee shop owner on Square Community used a $5 minimum on Square Loyalty and said about one person complained in years. In a Crate app the minimum to earn a stamp is yours to set, from $0 to $50, and it starts at $6, so every stamp is earned on an order worth the drink you give back.
Can the free drink leave out paid add-ons like cold foam?
Not today: the free drink in a Crate app is the most expensive drink in the order including its add-ons. Set your minimum spend to cover that, and the reward stays simple for your regulars: ten stamps, one drink they love, no fine print at the counter.
Will a Crate app show my customers' Square Loyalty points?
Not today. A Crate app runs its own stamps or points and does not show Square Loyalty balances or redeem Square rewards yet. Starting fresh is quick: regulars earn their first stamp on their next app or counter order, and the app tells them the moment a free drink is waiting.

Give your regulars a stamp card in your own app

Tell us about your coffee shop and your Square setup. We will show you what your app would look like and what it costs.

We use cookies for analytics and advertising to improve Crate and measure our ads. Essential cookies keep you signed in and are always on. See our Privacy Policy.