joe alternative

The joe alternative for cafes: Crate

Looking for a joe alternative? Keep your regulars in your own app, with your name on it and no other coffee shop to tap, for $80 a month flat.

By the Crate teamUpdated

The short answer

  • Keep your regulars in an app with only your shop in it. joe sells the opposite as a feature: 'Your regulars visit other shops while traveling', and the rewards they earn with you can be spent at any joe shop.
  • Crate builds your own iOS and Android app on your Square menu for $80/month, up to five locations, with rewards and push offers included and no Crate fee on any order. joe holds 6% of each loyalty transaction, about 1% by its own estimate and capped at 5% on its loyalty page: at $20,000 a month in loyalty sales that is $200 to $1,000, so Crate keeps you $120 to $920 a month.
Contents
  1. Why Crate wins
  2. What it costs
  3. Side by side
  4. What your cafe gets
  5. Questions
  6. Sources

Why pick Crate

  • Your regulars see only you. joe's loyalty page lists 'Reciprocal Traffic: Your regulars visit other shops while traveling', and its pricing page sells 'acquire from other joe shops'. Those are your regulars, handed to other shops. In your own app there is no other shop to tap, so the next coffee they order is from you. Source 1 Source 2
  • Rewards that bring them back to you. joe's rule is 'Earn at any Joe shop, redeem at any shop', so the free drink a regular earned at your counter can be spent at another shop. Crate stamps or points are earned in your app and at your Square counter, and redeemed only with you, which is the point of a reward. Source 1 Source 2
  • A flat price, not a share that grows with you. $80/month whether you take 100 app orders or 5,000, with no Crate fee per order. joe holds 6% of each loyalty transaction, puts its effective cost at about 1% and caps it at 5%: on $8,000 a month that is $80 to $400 against Crate's $80, and at $20,000 it is $200 to $1,000, so Crate keeps you $120 to $920 a month. Source 1 Source 2
  • Nothing changes at your counter. Crate runs on the Square account you already have: same menu, same register, and Square still processes your payments. joe's pricing is built around joe's own point of sale, processing and hardware. Source
  • Your own app, without the build. joe's case against having your own app is the cost: its CEO put a custom build at '$50,000-$150,000'. That is not the price anymore. Crate designs the app around your brand, submits it to the App Store and Google Play and keeps it updated, for $80/month. Source
  • You talk to your own customers. Slow afternoon, or a new seasonal drink? Send a push offer from your dashboard to customers who opted in. It is included, with no charge per message.

Where joe may still fit: if you are opening a shop with no point of sale yet and want joe's register, hardware and ordering in one, or if being found by new customers inside a shared app matters more to you than keeping your regulars in your own.

When Crate's flat price costs less than joe's loyalty hold

When Crate's flat price costs less than joe's loyalty hold
Loyalty sales a monthCratejoe
$5,000 a month$80/month, no fee per order. Up to $170 a month less than joe at its 5% cap; joe's own 1% estimate is about $30 less than Crate here.About $50 at joe's own 1% estimate, up to $250 at its 5% cap; $300 held at 6% before joe pays back discounts and promos.
$8,000 a month$80/month, no fee per order. Even with joe's 1% estimate; up to $320 a month less at its 5% cap. From here up, Crate costs less.About $80 at joe's own 1% estimate, up to $400 at its 5% cap; $480 held at 6% before joe pays back discounts and promos.
$20,000 a month$80/month. You keep about $120 a month ($1,440 a year) at joe's 1% estimate, up to $920 a month at its 5% cap.About $200 at joe's own 1% estimate, up to $1,000 at its 5% cap; $1,200 held at 6% before joe pays back discounts and promos.

Thinking about building your own app instead? See how much a coffee shop app costs, from a custom build to a white label subscription, with first-year totals.

Crate and joe, side by side

Crate and joe: cafe ordering compared
TopicCratejoe
Whose app it isYours. Your name and icon on the customer's home screen, in the App Store and Google Play.joe's. Customers open the joe app, 'The app for independent coffee'. Source
Who else is in itOnly your shop.Other joe shops. joe lists 'Network effect: acquire from other joe shops' as a feature. Source
RewardsYour own stamps or points, earned in the app and at your Square counter. Included.Universal Rewards: 'Earn at any Joe shop, redeem at any shop'. joe holds 6% of each loyalty transaction, about 1% by its own estimate, capped at 5% of loyalty-driven revenue. Source 1 Source 2
Price$80/month for up to five locations. No Crate fee per order and no revenue share.$0 subscription; 2.6% plus $0.30 per order-ahead transaction and 2.6% plus $0.10 in store, on joe's processing. Source
Register and paymentsKeep Square. Orders land on the register you already use. Clover is coming soon.Sells its own point of sale with hardware as a service; its Square App Marketplace listing says orders can arrive in your Square POS. Source 1 Source 2
Getting the app liveCrate designs it around your brand, submits it to both stores and keeps it updated.There is no app of your own to launch; your shop is added to joe's. Source
USD prices checked November 21, 2026. Processing and other provider charges are extra. Crate pricing.

What your cafe gets with Crate

An app designed around your brand, rewards included with no separate Square Loyalty subscription, and pickup plus shipping of beans and merchandise to US addresses.

Want to see how it connects before you decide? See how your own ordering app runs on your Square menu, with prices side by side.

Moving your Square cafe off joe? See what happens to your customers, Square Loyalty points and gift cards when you switch.

Explore Cafe ordering

Questions

What is the best joe alternative for a coffee shop on Square?
Crate, if you want to keep your regulars: your own branded iOS and Android app (the joe coffee app alternative with your name on the home screen), your own rewards, push offers, up to five locations, $80/month and no Crate fee per order. You keep your Square register, Crate handles the app store work, and above about $8,000 a month in loyalty sales you also pay less than joe's loyalty hold.
What is joe coffee, and do its rewards work at other shops?
joe (joe.coffee) is a shared ordering app for independent coffee shops: customers download the joe app, find shops near them and order ahead. Yes, its rewards work across shops: 'Earn at any Joe shop, redeem at any shop', and joe sells 'Reciprocal Traffic: Your regulars visit other shops while traveling'. joe also sells its own point of sale and payment processing. With Crate your shop gets its own iOS and Android app instead, with your name on it, only your menu in it and rewards your regulars can only spend with you, on your Square account, for $80/month.
How much does joe cost a coffee shop?
joe's pricing page lists $0 subscription fees, 2.6% plus $0.10 per in-store transaction, 2.6% plus $0.30 per order-ahead transaction, and a 6% hold on each loyalty transaction that it says works out to about 1%; its loyalty page caps that at 5% of loyalty-driven revenue. So joe's cost rises with your sales: at $20,000 a month in loyalty sales it is $200 to $1,000. Crate is $80/month flat for up to five locations with no Crate fee on orders (Square processing is separate), so once your loyalty sales pass about $8,000 a month Crate costs less, and at $20,000 you keep $120 to $920 a month.

Sources

Published by Crate from joe's published information, not a hands-on test. No affiliation or endorsement is implied.

Other comparisons

See Crate with your menu

Your own iOS and Android app with rewards, from your Square or Clover menu, for $80/month.

We use cookies for analytics and advertising to improve Crate and measure our ads. Essential cookies keep you signed in and are always on. See our Privacy Policy.